Are you confident that your psychiatry practice is being reimbursed correctly for every service you provide?

Many mental health professionals struggle with claim denials or delayed payments due to improper use of billing modifiers. But what exactly is a modifier?

A modifier is a two-character code added to a CPT or HCPCS code to show that a service or procedure has been altered in some way. This can include being performed on the same day as another service, delivered through telehealth, or requiring special documentation. As a result, knowing how and when to apply modifiers correctly is crucial for maximizing reimbursement, staying compliant with payer rules, and avoiding costly claim denials.

In this blog, we will discuss the proper use of modifiers in psychiatry billing and explore best practices for reimbursement.

Step 1: Identify the Type of Service Provided

The first step is to identify the services delivered during the visit clearly. Psychiatry visits may involve evaluation and management (E/M), psychotherapy, group therapy, or even crisis intervention. In many cases, more than one type of service is provided in the same encounter. For example, a psychiatrist may adjust medications while also providing a therapy session. Knowing the exact combination of services is the foundation for choosing the correct modifier.

Step 2: Determine if Services Are Distinct and Separately Identifiable

Once the services are identified, the next step is to check if they are distinct from one another. A service should only be billed separately when it exceeds the routine care that is typically bundled together. For instance, if a psychiatrist provides medication management and also performs a comprehensive evaluation for a new symptom, the E/M service is significant and separately identifiable. On the other hand, if the evaluation is part of the normal therapy session, no modifier is required.

Step 3: Select the Correct Modifier

Choosing the correct modifier is an important step in psychiatry billing as it helps explain the unique circumstances of a service and prevents claim denials. It includes:

• Modifier 25: For distinct E/M services

Use Modifier 25 when an evaluation and management (E/M) service is performed on the same day as another procedure, such as psychotherapy, and is clearly separate and documented.

• Modifier 59 or X modifiers (XE, XS, XP, XU): For distinct procedural services

These modifiers are used when two procedural services are distinct from each other. For example, they apply when both individual and group therapy are provided on the same day.

• Modifier 95 (or GT): For synchronous telehealth visits

Telepsychiatry services provided through live video should include Modifier 95, or GT when required by specific payers, to indicate that the session was conducted virtually.

• State-specific modifiers: For Medicaid or license-level rules

Some state Medicaid programs require special modifiers to identify provider type or license level. Always confirm payer-specific rules before submitting the claim.

Step 4: Document Thoroughly and Accurately

Strong documentation is the foundation of correct modifier use in psychiatry billing, as it ensures both compliance and proper reimbursement.

• Separate notes for each service

Always create clear and distinct notes for evaluation and management (E/M) services and for psychotherapy or other procedures so that each service stands on its own.

• Include clinical details and decision-making

Provide enough detail by recording history, assessment, and clinical decision-making, along with the medical need for each service performed during the visit.

• Record time and medical necessity

Document the time spent on every service and explain why it was necessary, as this supports modifier use and reduces denials.

Step 5: Apply Modifiers Correctly in the Claim

After completing the documentation, the next step is to apply modifiers correctly within the claim. In fact, each modifier should be linked to the appropriate CPT code to reflect the service provided accurately. It is also important to include the correct place-of-service code, particularly for telehealth claims, as payers often have specific requirements for virtual care. Additionally, following payer guidelines on where and how to apply modifiers is crucial for submitting clean claims. Even when services are performed and appropriately documented, mistakes at this stage can still result in denials, payment delays, or unnecessary compliance issues.

Step 6: Review Before Submission

Before submitting a claim, it is crucial to conduct a thorough review to ensure accuracy and compliance. You should verify that the selected modifier accurately matches the type of service provided and that the documentation fully supports its use. Next, verify that payer-specific requirements, such as telehealth indicators or Medicaid rules, are strictly adhered to. To minimize mistakes, many practices rely on claim scrubbers or EHR alerts, which can flag common errors like applying Modifier 59 instead of Modifier 25. This extra step not only saves time but also prevents denials, rework, and delays in reimbursement.

Step 7: Monitor, Audit, and Educate

Regular monitoring of modifier use is crucial for maintaining accurate and compliant psychiatry billing. Internal audits should be conducted by reviewing a sample of claims each month to identify errors, patterns, or trends that can lead to denials. Additionally, continuous education and training for clinicians and billing staff are equally important, as modifier guidelines and payer rules are often subject to change. Additionally, using quick reference guides or EHR templates helps ensure consistency in documentation and claim submission. Therefore, psychiatry practices can reduce compliance risks, improve accuracy, and safeguard their revenue by combining monitoring, auditing, and ongoing education.

Step 8: Best Practices for Maximizing Reimbursement

After following the steps for correct modifier use, implementing best practices can help psychiatry practices improve reimbursement, reduce denials, and maintain compliance. These can be:

• Prioritize Accurate E/M and Therapy Coding

Psychiatry visits often include evaluation and management (E/M), psychotherapy, and medication management in the same encounter. Accurately coding each distinct service and applying the appropriate modifiers ensures all billable services are reimbursed.

• Utilize Telepsychiatry Opportunities

With the rise of virtual mental health care, using modifiers like 95 correctly for telehealth visits ensures proper reimbursement. Practices should track telehealth sessions separately and confirm payer-specific rules to avoid denials.

• Optimize Documentation for Complex Cases

Complex psychiatric cases, such as patients with co-morbid conditions or crisis interventions, require detailed notes. Proper documentation of history, assessment, and clinical decision-making supports separate billing of multiple services on the same day.

• Track Psychiatry-Specific Metrics

Monitoring denial rates for psychotherapy, medication management, and crisis visits helps identify recurring issues. Tracking revenue per patient and service type highlights missed billing opportunities and guides corrective action.

Leverage Offshore Psychiatry Billing and Coding Services in India

Outsourcing psychiatry billing to Info hub Consultancy Services can significantly improve accuracy and efficiency in psychiatry practices. In fact, experienced billing teams are well-versed in modifier guidelines, payer-specific rules, and documentation requirements, which reduces the risk of denials and compliance issues. Additionally, outsourcing psychiatry billing and coding service providers in India has access to advanced billing software, audit support, and ongoing regulatory updates, which help identify overlooked revenue opportunities and optimize overall financial performance. Therefore, this approach enhances both compliance and practice profitability.

FAQs

Q. Can modifiers be applied retroactively after claim submission?

Ans. No, corrections require claim adjustments or resubmission with proper modifiers.

Q. Can modifiers be used for group therapy sessions?

Ans. Specific modifiers like 59 or X variants can indicate distinct services within group therapy.

Q. Do modifiers impact reimbursement rates for crisis interventions?

Ans. Correct modifier use ensures crisis services are reimbursed as separate, billable visits.

Q. Can multiple modifiers be used on a single CPT code?

Ans. Yes, when different circumstances affect the service, multiple modifiers can be applied

Related Blogs

Medicare Telehealth Rules Are Changing—Here’s What Providers Need to Know

Medicare telehealth rules are undergoing a significant transition, and 2025 is the year providers must remain vigilant. The temporary flexibilities Read more

Effective Strategies to Code Multiple Procedures and Optimize Facility Fees in Mental Health

Do you often wonder why your claims for multiple procedures get denied? Or why do facility fees not reflect the Read more

CPT 90837 vs. 90834: Billing Psychotherapy Without Losing RVUs

Choosing between CPT codes 90834 and 90837 is not only about documenting session length, but also about aligning clinical practice Read more